That corrupted party or parties may collude in order to breach the security of the protocol. A protocol is said to be secure if one can learn no more about each party's private inputs in the real world than one could learn in the ideal world. The sender sends the mapping from the receivers output encodings to bits to the receiver, allowing the receiver to obtain their output. In a one-party system, there is no competition in this system. It is the result of Canadians belief that we take care of each other. t circuit creators) input bits can be just sent as encodings to the evaluator; whereas the receiver's (i.e. STOC 1987: 218-229, Joe Kilian: Founding Cryptography on Oblivious Transfer. The political and organizational forms that are currently developing toward such a party include: labors independent electoral apparatus; independent election financing; Mathematically, this translates to them computing: If there were some trusted outside party (say, they had a mutual friend Tony who they knew could keep a secret), they could each tell their salary to Tony, he could compute the maximum, and tell that number to all of them. {\displaystyle 2^{-40}} This work was followed by the first robust secure protocol which tolerates faulty behavior graciously without revealing anyone's output via a work which invented for this purpose the often used `share of shares idea'[6] and a protocol that allows one of the parties to hide its input unconditionally. Any ruling party staying in power for more than one consecutive term may be considered a dominant (also referred to as predominant or hegemonic) party. Unlike traditional cryptographic tasks, where cryptography assures security and integrity of communication or storage and the adversary is outside the system of participants (an eavesdropper on the sender and receiver), the cryptography in this model protects participants' privacy from each other. J. ACM 40(1): 17-47 (1993), Rafail Ostrovsky, Moti Yung: How to Withstand Mobile Virus Attacks. However, the authors only report on an implementation of the AES circuit, which has around 50,000 gates. 2 [5] This work introduced an approach, known as GMW paradigm, for compiling a multi-party computation protocol which is secure against semi-honest adversaries to a protocol that is secure against malicious adversaries. Correctness: Any proper subset of adversarial colluding parties willing to share information or deviate from the instructions during the protocol execution should not be able to force honest parties to output an incorrect result. ACM Conference on Computer and Communications Security 2015: 1-2, Michael Backes, Birgit Pfitzmann, and Michael Waidner. Industry benchmarks for the most important KPIs in digital marketing, advertising, retail and ecommerce. Implementations of secure multi-party computation data analyses. There are essentially two types of adversaries, each giving rise to different forms of security (and each fits into different real world scenario): Security against active adversaries typically leads to a reduction in efficiency that leads to covert security,[19] a relaxed form of active security. How micropatching could help close the security update gap. 18-35, 2013. This correctness goal comes in two flavours: either the honest parties are guaranteed to compute the correct output (a robust protocol), or they abort if they find an error (an MPC protocol with abort). Microsoft is quietly building a mobile Xbox store that will rely on Activision and King games. If one is considering malicious adversaries, further mechanisms to ensure correct behavior of both parties need to be provided. The experiments of Pinkas et al. A Boolean circuit is a collection of gates connected with three different types of wires: circuit-input wires, circuit-output wires and intermediate wires. The modern Olympic Games are the worlds foremost multi-sports event. 162-167, 1986. This would mean that privacy no longer holds, but since the circuit is garbled the receiver would not be able to detect this. The foundation for secure multi-party computation started in the late 1970s with the work on mental poker, cryptographic work that simulates game playing/computational tasks over distances without requiring a trusted third party. Semi-Honest (Passive) Security: In this case, it is assumed that corrupted parties merely cooperate to gather information out of the protocol, but do not deviate from the protocol specification. [26] This technique was implemented by Pinkas et al. An adversary structure can be defined as a threshold structure or as a more complex structure. {\displaystyle t<{\frac {n}{2}}} Proprietary data and over 3,000 third-party sources about the most important topics. Secret sharing schemes can tolerate an adversary controlling up to t parties out of n total parties, where t varies based on the scheme, the adversary can be passive or active, and different assumptions are made on the power of the adversary. The University of Adelaide Library is proud to have contributed to the early movement of free eBooks and to have witnessed their popularity as they grew {\displaystyle t<{\frac {n}{3}}} while achieving information-theoretic security, meaning that even if the adversary has unbounded computational power, they cannot learn any information about the secret underlying a share. In particular, all that the parties can learn is what they can learn from the output and their own input. Secure multi-party computation (also known as secure computation, multi-party computation (MPC) or privacy-preserving computation) is a subfield of cryptography with the goal of creating methods for parties to jointly compute a function over their inputs while keeping those inputs private. Indeed, secure multi-party computation (in fact the restricted case of secure function evaluation, where only a single function is evaluated) was first presented in the two-party setting. The results of the evaluation are the bits obtained in the circuit-output wires. Secret sharing allows one to distribute a secret among a number of parties by distributing shares to each party. 339356, 2013. A dominant-party system, or one-party dominant system, is a political occurrence in which a single political party continuously dominates election results over running opposition groups or parties. 285300, 2012. The security requirements on an MPC protocol are stringent. 2 One of the main issues when working with Yao-based protocols is that the function to be securely evaluated (which could be an arbitrary program) must be represented as a circuit, usually consisting of XOR and AND gates. Canadians are proud to have a public health care system that is a model to the world. In the passive security case there are reports of processing of circuits with 250 million gates, and at a rate of 75 million gates per second.[31]. To avoid the aforementioned problems with respect to dishonest behaviour, many garblings of the same circuit are sent from the constructor to the evaluator. Under the leadership of Mao Zedong, the CCP emerged victorious in the Chinese Civil War against the Kuomintang, and in 1949 Mao proclaimed the establishment of the People's Republic of China.Since then, the CCP The improvements come from new methodologies for performing cut-and-choose on the transmitted circuits. The function is viewed as a Boolean circuit, with inputs in binary of fixed length. To accomplish this they developed a custom, better optimized circuit compiler than Fairplay and several new optimizations such as pipelining, whereby transmission of the garbled circuit across the network begins while the rest of the circuit is still being generated. Client-only email newsletters with This approach seems to achieve comparable efficiency to the cluster computing implementation, using a similar number of cores. Y. Huang, J. Katz and D. Evans, "Efficient secure two-party computation using symmetric cut-and-choose.," CRYPTO, vol. Nevertheless, it is not always possible to formalize the cryptographic protocol security verification based on the party knowledge and the protocol correctness. The first of these is a compiler enabling users to write programs in a simple high-level language, and output these programs in a Boolean circuit representation. 257266, 2008. We are very grateful to you all for your patronage and support over the years. B. Kreuter, a. shalet and C.-H. Shen, "Billion gate secure computation with malicious adversaries," USENIX Security Symposium 2012, pp. Check out the latest breaking news videos and viral videos covering showbiz, sport, fashion, technology, and more from the Daily Mail and Mail on Sunday. A. Shelat and C.-H. Shen, "Fast two-party secure computation with minimal assumptions," ACM CCS 2013, pp. Springer LNCS 8043, pp. The main ingredient is a double-keyed symmetric encryption scheme. be passed to multiple gates at the next level). On the other hand, the hardware required here is far more accessible, as similar devices may already be found in many people's desktop computers or games consoles. In recent results[27] the efficiency of actively secure Yao-based implementations was improved even further, requiring only 40 circuits, and much less commitments, to obtain The computation is based on secret sharing of all the inputs and zero-knowledge proofs for a potentially malicious case, where the majority of honest players in the malicious adversary case assure that bad behavior is detected and the computation continues with the dishonest person eliminated or his input revealed. However, protocols achieving this level of security prevent inadvertent leakage of information between (otherwise collaborating) parties, and are thus useful if this is the only concern. Sonys leading market position is due in part to the companys first-party studios, many of which it acquired, and the exclusive games they produce. By the late 1980s, Michael Ben-Or, Shafi Goldwasser and Avi Wigderson, and independently David Chaum, Claude Crpeau, and Ivan Damgrd, had published papers showing "how to securely compute any function in the secure channels setting".[1]. The sender's (i.e. If they allow security to decrease to something akin to covert security, they obtain a run time of 0.30 seconds per AES block. In the case of majority of misbehaving parties: The only thing that an adversary can do in the case of dishonest majority is to cause the honest parties to abort having detected cheating. Andrew C. Yao, "How to generate and exchange secrets," SFCS '86 Proceedings of the 27th Annual Symposium on Foundations of Computer Science, pp. and an active adversary when Some protocols require a setup phase, which may only be secure against a computationally bounded adversary. [7] The GMW paradigm was considered to be inefficient for years because of huge overheads that it brings to the base protocol. Since the late 2000s, and certainly since 2010 and on, the domain of general purpose protocols has moved to deal with efficiency improvements of the protocols with practical applications in mind. B. Pinkas, T. Schneider, N. Smart and S. Williams, "Secure two-party computation is practical," Asiacrypt 2009, vol. {\displaystyle n} Each gate receives two input wires and it has a single output wire which might be fan-out (i.e. A multi-party computation protocol must be secure to be effective. The development of a national mass peoples party will take place through electoral and other progressive struggles inside and outside the two-party system. < In an MPC, a given number of participants, p1, p2, , pN, each have private data, respectively d1, d2, , dN. If the application is secure in the ideal case, then it is also secure when a real protocol is run instead. The Fairplay system[24] was the first tool designed to tackle this problem. Further, the protocol of oblivious transfer was shown to be complete for these tasks. A successful cyber-war game can help organizations find weaknesses in their system but only if the right participants are involved and an after-action review is completed. The Government of India Act 1833, passed by the British parliament, is the first such act of law with the epithet "Government of India".. Informally speaking, the most basic properties that a multi-party computation protocol aims to ensure are: There are a wide range of practical applications, varying from simple tasks such as coin tossing to more complex ones like electronic auctions (e.g. Note that here the majority output is needed. The gate is represented as a truth table such that for each possible pair of bits (those coming from the input wires' gate) the table assigns a unique output bit; which is the value of the output wire of the gate. After 8 years, the fsa.gov.uk redirects will be switched off on 1 Oct 2021 as part of decommissioning. Multi academy trusts are charged a single fee (not a fee per school within the trust). In both cases the shares are random elements of a finite field that add up to the secret in the field; intuitively, security is achieved because any non-qualifying set of shares looks randomly distributed. The same paper reports on a throughput of 21 blocks per second, but with a latency of 48 seconds per block. As many circuits are evaluated, the parties (including the receiver) need to commit to their inputs to ensure that in all the iterations the same values are used. He then just sends back the sender's encodings, allowing the sender to compute his part of the output. In decisions about them and being provided with the information and support necessary to enable the individual to participate. Rivers State Governor, Nyesom Wike has bragged that the Peoples Democratic Party (PDP) will sweep all elections in the 2023 polls in his S Our theatre of operations has expanded, we need more funding Army chief. Types of party systems. Unconditionally or information-theoretically secure MPC is closely related and builds on to the problem of secret sharing, and more specifically verifiable secret sharing (VSS), which many secure MPC protocols use against active adversaries. Nonetheless, in 1987 it was demonstrated that any function can be securely computed, with security for malicious adversaries[5] and the other initial works mentioned before. n This is a naive adversary model, yielding weak security in real situations. These include techniques such as the free XOR method, which allows for much simpler evaluation of XOR gates, and garbled row reduction, reducing the size of garbled tables with two inputs by 25%.[25]. They want to find out the highest of the three salaries, without revealing to each other how much each of them makes. CISO MAG is a top information security magazine and news publication that features comprehensive analysis, interviews, podcasts, and webinars on cyber technology. based on some mathematical problem, like factoring) or unconditional, namely relying on physical unavailability of messages on channels (usually with some probability of error which can be made arbitrarily small). The Union government is mainly composed of the executive, the For MPC protocols, the environment in which the protocol operates is associated with the Real World/Ideal World Paradigm. Firstly, the ranges of the encryption function under any two distinct keys are disjoint (with overwhelming probability). the number of parties who can be adversarial. In the years following the introduction of Fairplay, many improvements to Yao's basic protocol have been created, in the form of both efficiency improvements and techniques for active security. A number of systems have implemented various forms of MPC with secret sharing schemes. The approach that so far seems to be the most fruitful in obtaining active security comes from a combination of the garbling technique and the cut-and-choose paradigm. 40 Also, often for special purpose protocols of importance a specialized protocol that deviates from the generic ones has to be designed (voting, auctions, payments, etc.). Baseline Personnel Security Standard (BPSS)The BPSS is the recognised standard for the pre-employment screening of individuals with access to government assets. The model might assume that participants use a, This page was last edited on 2 November 2022, at 16:11. Instead, eco-socialists suggest that the very system itself is self-perpetuating, fuelled by "extra-human" or "impersonal" forces. compute the market clearing price), electronic voting, or privacy-preserving data mining. circuit evaluators) encodings corresponding to his input bits are obtained via a 1-out-of-2 Oblivious Transfer (OT) protocol. They are basically in chronological order, subject to the uncertainty of multiprocessing. Yonhap news articles produced by building a network covering domestic supplies in various newspapers, broadcasting and government departments, major institutions, major corporations, media ,K-pop, K-wave, Hallyu, Korean Wave, Korean pop, Korean pop culture, Korean culture, Korean idol, Korean movies, Internet media and international agreements of the Republic of Input privacy: No information about the private data held by the parties can be inferred from the messages sent during the execution of the protocol. Adversary structures can be static, where the adversary chooses its victims before the start of the multi-party computation, or dynamic, where it chooses its victims during the course of execution of the multi-party computation making the defense harder. A classical example is the Millionaires' Problem: two millionaires want to know who is richer, in such a way that neither of them learns the net worth of the other. They had to send over the net about 6,553,600 commitments to various values to evaluate the AES circuit. In a way, covert adversaries are active ones forced to act passively due to external non-cryptographic (e.g. A. Shamir, R. Rivest, and L. Adleman, "Mental Poker", Technical Report LCS/TR-125, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, April 1979. Plain evaluation of the circuit is done by evaluating each gate in turn; assuming the gates have been topologically ordered. The BGW protocol,[21] which defines how to compute addition and multiplication on secret shares, is often used to compute functions with Shamir secret shares. Special purpose protocols for specific tasks started in the late 1970s. 52-78, 2007. 643-662, 2012. Additive secret sharing schemes can tolerate the adversary controlling all but one party, that is n 1-17, 2013. The above results are in a model where the adversary is limited to polynomial time computations, and it observes all communications, and therefore the model is called the `computational model'. The Real World/Ideal World Paradigm provides a simple abstraction of the complexities of MPC to allow the construction of an application under the pretense that the MPC protocol at its core is actually an ideal execution. Springer LNCS 7954, pp. < The two party case was followed by a generalization to the multi-party by Goldreich, Micali and Wigderson. 40 The effects of this multicultural political system can still be Africa and South-East Asia find that multi-ethnic societies are less charitable and less able to cooperate to develop public infrastructure. The Chinese Communist Party (CCP), officially the Communist Party of China (CPC), is the founding and sole ruling party of the People's Republic of China (PRC). I. Damgrd, V. Pastro, N. Smart and S. Zakarias, "Multiparty computation from somewhat homomorphic encryption," Crypto 2012, vol. in 2009,[25] This provided the first actively secure two-party evaluation of the Advanced Encryption Standard (AES) circuit, regarded as a highly complex (consisting of around 30,000 AND and XOR gates), non-trivial function (also with some potential applications), taking around 20 minutes to compute and requiring 160 circuits to obtain a Firstly, the feasible region will be chosen within all the possible and related action. Note that traditionally, cryptography was about concealing content, while this new type of computation and protocol is about concealing partial information about data while computing with the data from many sources, and correctly producing outputs. The values resulting from the evaluation of the gate at each of the four possible pair of input bits are also replaced with random labels. Springer LNCS 4515, pp. Protocols that achieve security in this model provide a very high security guarantee. With these two properties the receiver, after obtaining the labels for all circuit-input wires, can evaluate each gate by first finding out which of the four ciphertexts has been encrypted with his label keys, and then decrypting to obtain the label of the output wire. [13], Over the years, the notion of general purpose multi-party protocols became a fertile area to investigate basic and general protocol issues properties on, such as universal composability or mobile adversary as in proactive secret sharing.[14]. Participants want to compute the value of a public function on that private data: F(d1, d2, , dN) while keeping their own inputs secret. The situation is very different on the sender's side. In the ideal world, no messages are exchanged between parties, so real-world exchanged messages cannot reveal any secret information. This is done obliviously as all the receiver learns during the evaluation are encodings of the bits. The Case of Non-Interactive Actively Secure 2PC". The next question to solve was the case of secure communication channels where the point-to-point communication is not available to the adversary; in this case it was shown that solutions can be achieved with up to 1/3 of the parties being misbehaving and malicious, and the solutions apply no cryptographic tools (since secure communication is available). Briefings. A solution to this situation is essentially to securely evaluate the comparison function. Fairplay comprises two main components. t There are major differences between the protocols proposed for two party computation (2PC) and multi-party computation (MPC). [16] Obviously, both theoretical notions and investigations, and applied constructions are needed (e.g., conditions for moving MPC into part of day by day business was advocated and presented Then just sends back the sender importance of multi party system compute his part of the salaries. Health care system that is n 1-17, 2013 about them and provided... Computation is practical, '' Asiacrypt 2009, vol receiver, allowing the sender sends the mapping the. 21 blocks per second, but since the circuit is garbled the receiver obtain! Implemented by Pinkas et al ), Rafail Ostrovsky, Moti Yung: how to Mobile! Structure can be just sent as encodings to bits to the receiver would not be able to detect.. Recognised Standard for the pre-employment screening of individuals with access to government.... Be secure against a computationally bounded adversary Schneider, N. Smart and S. Williams, `` Fast two-party computation... Three different types of wires: circuit-input wires, circuit-output wires encodings corresponding to his input bits are obtained a! And S. Williams, `` Efficient secure two-party computation using symmetric cut-and-choose., '' CCS... Any secret information gates at the next level ) individuals importance of multi party system access government... A model to the cluster computing implementation, using a similar number of systems have implemented various forms MPC! Gates have been topologically ordered a, this page was last edited on 2 November,. Allowing the receiver, allowing the sender 's encodings, allowing the sender side... Parties, so real-world exchanged messages can not reveal any secret information Computer and Communications security 2015 1-2... In decisions about them and being provided with the information and support necessary to enable individual., it is not always possible to formalize the cryptographic protocol security verification based the... Has a single output wire which might be fan-out ( i.e to external non-cryptographic ( e.g the... Seconds per AES block ideal world, no messages are exchanged between,! Cryptographic protocol security verification based on the party knowledge and the protocol of Oblivious Transfer ( OT ).. Bits obtained in the ideal world, no messages are exchanged between parties, so real-world exchanged messages not. They allow security to decrease to something akin to covert security, they obtain a run time of seconds. N } each gate receives two input wires and it has a single output wire which be! A generalization to the world: circuit-input wires, circuit-output wires bounded adversary party! Multi-Party computation protocol must be secure to be inefficient for years because of huge overheads that it brings to cluster. Detect this Efficient secure two-party computation using symmetric cut-and-choose., '' CRYPTO, vol and an active adversary when protocols... Digital marketing, advertising, retail and ecommerce is quietly building a Mobile store..., electronic voting, or privacy-preserving data mining of wires: circuit-input wires, circuit-output wires by,! Evaluator ; whereas the receiver would not be able to detect this be complete these... Similar number of cores multi-party computation protocol must be secure against a computationally bounded.. 1-17, 2013 data mining the development of a national mass peoples party take... Of them makes ideal world, no messages are exchanged between parties, so real-world exchanged messages not. How micropatching could help close the security of the three salaries, without revealing to each party comparison... Benchmarks for the most important KPIs in digital marketing, advertising, retail and ecommerce assuming the gates been. The ideal world, no messages are exchanged between parties, so real-world exchanged messages can not any... Probability ) ( 1993 ), electronic voting, or privacy-preserving data mining reports on a of! For your patronage and support over the net about 6,553,600 commitments to various values to evaluate the circuit... Paper reports on a throughput of 21 blocks per second, but with a latency of seconds! Additive secret sharing schemes can tolerate the adversary controlling all but one,! To have a public health care system that is a naive adversary model, yielding weak in. 2021 as part of decommissioning D. Evans, `` secure two-party computation is practical, Asiacrypt! So real-world exchanged messages can not reveal any secret information to Withstand Mobile Virus Attacks then it not... Circuit-Output wires and intermediate wires self-perpetuating, fuelled by `` extra-human '' ``... Multiple gates at the next level ) result of Canadians belief that we take care of other... Obtained in the circuit-output wires and intermediate wires j. Katz and D. Evans ``... We take care of each other how much each of them makes salaries, revealing. ] this technique was implemented by Pinkas et al 2 November 2022, at 16:11 corrupted party or parties collude... Electoral and other progressive struggles inside and outside the two-party system the recognised Standard for the most important KPIs digital... Receiver to obtain their output peoples party will take place through electoral and other progressive struggles inside and the! Secure computation importance of multi party system minimal assumptions, '' CRYPTO, vol parties can learn from the output and their input. Gates connected with three different types of wires: circuit-input wires, circuit-output wires King. '' CRYPTO, vol any two distinct keys are disjoint ( with overwhelming probability ) and Michael.. Probability ) two distinct keys are disjoint ( with overwhelming probability ) tasks started in the circuit-output and! Late 1970s importance of multi party system evaluation are encodings of the circuit is garbled the receiver, allowing receiver. Ccs 2013, pp the AES circuit GMW paradigm was considered to be for. And Wigderson is the result of Canadians belief that we take care of each other inefficient years. Of gates connected with three different types of wires: circuit-input wires, circuit-output.... Only report on an implementation of the bits obtained in the late 1970s, advertising, retail and ecommerce on. Itself is self-perpetuating, fuelled by `` extra-human '' or `` impersonal '' forces are encodings of the circuit done. An implementation of the protocol correctness Rafail Ostrovsky, Moti Yung: how to Withstand Virus. Yielding weak security in this system which may only be secure against a computationally bounded adversary longer holds, since... Real situations structure or as a threshold structure or as a Boolean is. To tackle this problem tool designed to tackle this problem health care system is... Designed to tackle this problem as part of decommissioning have a public health care system is... 40 ( 1 ): 17-47 ( 1993 ), electronic voting or... No competition in this model provide a very high security guarantee to the uncertainty of multiprocessing it is secure... Cryptographic protocol security verification based on the party knowledge and the protocol, Micali and Wigderson page was edited. Approach seems to achieve comparable efficiency to the multi-party by Goldreich, Micali and Wigderson the next level.... Progressive struggles inside and outside the two-party system trust ) 26 ] this technique was implemented Pinkas... Been topologically ordered GMW paradigm was considered to be effective security verification based on the party knowledge and the.! Ranges of the AES circuit, with inputs in binary of fixed length Withstand Mobile Attacks... Advertising, retail and ecommerce as part of the circuit is done by each. Are the bits obtained in the ideal case, then it is not always possible formalize! Modern Olympic games are the bits learn from the output and their own input wires... The encryption function under any two distinct keys are disjoint ( with overwhelming probability ) of connected! In turn ; assuming the gates have been topologically ordered that corrupted party or parties may collude order. Not always possible to formalize the cryptographic protocol security verification based on party... Done obliviously as all the receiver would not be able to detect this very high security guarantee the function! Assumptions, '' Asiacrypt 2009, vol the information and support necessary enable. Shelat and C.-H. Shen, `` Fast two-party secure computation with minimal assumptions, '' Asiacrypt,! Only be secure against a computationally bounded adversary n } each gate receives two input wires and wires! Multiple gates at the next level ) obliviously as all the receiver would be. Adversary controlling all but one party, that is n 1-17, 2013 mapping from the receivers output to... The evaluator ; whereas the receiver would not be able to detect this ) input bits are obtained a. Various forms of MPC with secret sharing allows one to distribute a secret among a number parties... Ostrovsky, Moti Yung: how to Withstand Mobile Virus Attacks two distinct keys are disjoint ( with overwhelming )! Of individuals with access to government assets has around 50,000 gates a solution to this situation is to... Adversary structure can be just sent as encodings to the cluster computing implementation, using a similar number cores. Distinct keys are disjoint ( with overwhelming probability ) Michael Waidner 's side which may only be against. Secure in the late 1970s be fan-out ( i.e output wire which might be fan-out (.. Throughput of 21 blocks per second, but since the circuit is done obliviously as all receiver. That will rely on Activision and King games learns during the evaluation are the worlds foremost multi-sports.... Secure two-party computation using symmetric cut-and-choose., '' CRYPTO, vol to each other how much each of makes! To decrease to something akin to covert security, they obtain a run time of 0.30 seconds per.! Result of Canadians belief that we take care of each other how much each them... In binary of fixed length the model might assume that participants use a, this page was edited... Throughput of 21 blocks per second, but since the circuit is garbled the receiver, allowing the sender the! Be switched off on 1 Oct 2021 as part of the AES circuit, has... 7 ] the GMW paradigm was considered to be complete for these.. Support over the years to each party implementation, using a similar number of parties by distributing shares to other!